The food was good, but the service and atmosphere is what truly stood out to make this a great place! Wait staff was super friendly... Truly the nicest experienced in our trip to New York. I believe it to be one of the owners who came out. She told us about the "Italian" sandwich which we ordered for our daughter. She said that it probably isn't the type we were thinking of and when she saw my daughter didn't like it because it was so different... She came back with another "Italian" sandwich made in the way my daughter was used to at no extra cost! Wow, who does things like that anymore? Especially in New York! It truly stood out among all the restaurants we visited in our week of vacation, thank you! By the way, I ate that sandwich the next morning for breakfast... It was super delicious... Just different than what my daughter was used to for an "Italian".

For fresh and flavorful Asian cuisine on the go, Salt & Pepper on Broadway Monticello is a must-try. The friendly staff ensures a seamless takeout experience, and the minimal wait time is a plus. Don't worry about front parking; ample space is available in the back. Recommended for a delicious takeout meal! For the dining in please do not have high expectations, they use cheap silverware, still recommend.

OUTSTANDING! All is made from scratch and really fresh! I have a gluten and tree nut allergy and the owner and the staff were very mindful of this. The chicken dish shown here is what I got and it was so tasty! My cousin got the wrap and loved it. She also said the fries were to die for! Can't wait to go back! YUMMM!

What a delicious experience! The menu is delicious, with everything made fresh to order. It's cozy, the staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating - everything you could want from a relaxed meal. Looking forward to my next visit already!

We went with 16 people and had an absolutely amazing time! What an experience!! The food was incredible the service was very accommodating. Prices were reasonable and we will definitely be back. The grounds were beautiful- thank you so much.

Really neat place. The food portion were generous and decent. The RV that is available for rent is very well accommodating. All the food comes from the farm on site. Great get together spot. They have a game room with billard, karaoke, and majong. Payment method is done through cash or zelle. Not credit card payment.

First..let me ask has anyone around here eaten good Chinese food?? This place is terrible! Rice had no taste, beef on a stick burned to a crisp, sesame chicken..never had it made badly so figured it was safe..also no taste and boneless ribs over cooked and crispy but at least edible..eggroll falling apart also no taste..Guessing stomach aches later..2 stars only for the crispy but not burnt ribs..Anyone giving 4 or 5 stars have iron clad stomachs and need to try good Chinese food and then leave a rating..If you have decent taste in food, skip this place!!!!

I’m an old customer and I love this restaurant! Boneless ribs and sweet sour chicken tastes so good! The workers are super friendly and nice. I love eating in the back in the summertime.

I love this place it's about 45 minute drive to get here but we'll worth it. I love the buffalo chicken sandwhich it's super spicy which i love. They have a great beer menu too and bar with lots of choices. Lots of seating! Parking fills up quick though.

Great selection of draft beers! We tried the seasonal Octoberfest & the Pumking with the caramel rim to celebrate the season. Our burgers were perfectly cooked medium rare & the Buffalo chicken wings were full of flavor — everything was tasty. There was a little kitchen mishap with one of our orders but our server was quick to resolve, and it was much appreciated. Alicia — you were wonderful! Thank you so much for the exemplary service! Another plus about this spot is that it’s open during the week as well in contrast to most restaurants in the area. My partner and I look forward to returning here next time we are in the Catskills!

The food itself is one of the better Chinese food places in the county. The service is dreadfully annoying though. They always "forget" items and the prices are made up every time. How about including the egg rolls that are supposed to come with the combo? How about an itemized receipt? How about being the slightest bit pleasant, helpful, or understanding? Just know you're going to get ripped off one way or another here. Consider it a mandatory tip.

I always get shrimp and broccoli with black bean sauce and it is always excellent….way better than Chinese places on Long Island.

Was supposed to be garlic sauce but it’s regular brown and broccoli hard as if they just warmed it up and put it in bowl sad definitely not the same fell off completely never eating again.

Food is top-notch! And the lady who took our order was so friendly and kind that I began to ascend to the furthest dimensions of the universe. I highly recommend this place without hesitation.

In my opinion this is the best Chinese restaurant in Liberty. Tasty food and I can count on the consistency in the flavor of the dishes. The cashiers are always polite and friendly.

My whole family loves this Chinese place. We eat here every week. Food is great

This place was amazing. Great service from Yuki such a sweet soul. The manager Sarah had outstanding hospitality was very attentive to us and the restaurant in general she was on it. The chef kudos to him peaking duck was delicious thank you for a great dining experience.

The staff here are really attentive and the drinks are delicious. The food however is just ok. There was nothing that tasted bad but nothing stood out as amazing. For Asian food at this price, I'd expect fresh garlic, ginger, spices and herbs. The ambiance is amazing though. Beautiful bar area and dining room. But the food is far from fine dining.

I absolutely love China Star! The food is great, when it's fresh, and that's not always the case for the buffet but they'll make something fresh if you ask for it. It's a little expensive but worth it, to me. I only wish they would open the last bar up like it was before Covid. The only reason they didn't get 5 stars is because of the waitress. She wants to stare you down as if you're going to steal something and then she asks you how much of a tip you want to give when she takes your payment. I just don't think that's right at all.

For 2 years this has been my ONLY good result of yummy food, until today. This was in the vat of egg drop soup. When I brought it to their attention, the manager (maybe owner) doubled down on defending the food. He said repeatedly that it was egg, and it was fine, and something to do with the cooking process. As if I wasn't grossed out enough, he started playing in the cup, smooshing it, and approached me with it on his finger. I had to tell him not to come near me with that, it was gross,and he finally walked away. If that's egg, then it's rotten egg, if it's not egg then it's mold. That is not the only bit that looked like that, it's just all I cared to put in the bowl to subject my eyes to. They still insisted I paid full price for our lunch. 37.00 for this

Good basic staple Chinese restaurant. I had gone there many times as a kid and now I still pick up food here when I'm in town. I appreciate the dependable vegetarian options in an area where that's not common on menus.

WOW! I drove all the way from NYC to eat at this restaurant because my friend recommended it to me! This is probably my all time favorite Chinese food. Their chicken wings are so delicious and I think they gave me the power to fly. Bawk bawk bawk bawk bawk! Highly recommend!

Here on a Wednesday. And I’m stating this because perhaps it’s better on a Friday or Saturday to have such great reviews? This place has 3.9 stars so I’m curious when the food would be almost a 4⭐️ because on Wednesday nights is not that great. If Google would do 1/2 ⭐️ I’d rate the food tonight at 2.5 ⭐️. Now I did find a few items that were better than the rest and I will list those so read on General Tao’s chicken was good but I have had better The chicken wings were great The tempura fried shrimp were tasty Everything else was either over cooked and mushy or was old and dried out. The chicken wings, ok I said I can eat these and be done until this lady in a scooter rolls up to the buffet and begins to bulls a scaled down version of the Egyptian pyramids. I’m guessing she stacked a good 30 wings on her plate. It was actually quite the site to see this being built and I’m estimating that she had at least 10” of chicken wing vertical height happening. Unfortunately for me they didn’t replace the wings, I guess in fear that one of the sphinx would be constructed next. I pickle around with small portions so not to be wasteful but there wasn’t any thing to be excited about and certainly nothing worthy of a 4 stars. Second plate in the waitress brings the check and says “thank you for coming”in a loud voice like I was old with the large outside the ear hearing aids, my grandpa used to wear and then ignores me the rest of the evening. Don’t you just hate that ugh. I don’t recommend eating here just look at the picture of the soup they had out. Again maybe on a weekend this is the place to be but I’d pass on this place during the week. So food 👎🏼 Service 👎🏼 Price for what was offered tonight 👎🏼 Happy eating

This place was very unexpected. The food was well seasoned and tasted fresh. There was nothing I tried that was bad. The sevice was also wonderful. Thr waitress was very friendly and kind. The only negative about this place was the decor. The restaurant could definitely use some TLC. The booths were old and falling apart. If the setup was better, this would be almost a 5 star.