I Ordered 2 turkey sandwiches on a toasted bagel with mayo bacon and onion. Opened up sandwich and it was ‘turkey bacon’ with onion and mayo. I called them and said there was no turkey on the sandwich. They said I ordered a turkey-bacon sandwich. What? Who orders just turkey-bacon on a bagel?? I asked for them to please remake it and I would be back. They then wanted to charge me the difference after having driven 20 min back to return it. Unfortunately I didn’t have enough $$ bc it’s cash only and I didn’t have a debit card so I was $2 short. So I could only take the 1 sandwich. You would think that he would have said just take it for the inconvenience, but no. So needless to say he lost a frequent customer and I will be sure to pass this story on.

Another average bagel shop. Wouldn’t go out of my way to visit again.

Attilio’s is a bit nostalgic. It reminds me of when my kids were young and we would grab a fast, hearty dinner before tennis during the week. The food is pretty good, I especially like the puttanesca sauce on rigatoni or their garlic and oil pasta.

The Sicilian slice goes so hard you have to get this slice when you come here. Dough is crispy but airy and not tough to chew. Sauce is top tier. Solid cheese & seasoning. 10/10 every slice is awesome. Their entrees are also incredible, juicy chicken, not over cooked, and the chicken murphy is over the top awesome.