PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA

Chinese Restaurant New York Suffolk County New York 25A

170 reviews

99 NY-25A #4, Shoreham, NY 11786, USA
+1 631-744-3344
webSite

Hours

Monday, 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Tuesday, 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Wednesday, 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Thursday, 10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Friday, 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday, 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sunday, 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

About PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA

PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA is located at 99 NY-25A #4, Shoreham, NY 11786, USA. While categorized on some platforms as a Chinese Restaurant, PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA primarily offers pizza and likely other Italian-American dishes.

You can reach them at (631) 744-3344 or via mobile at +1 631-744-3344 for orders and inquiries.

Customer experiences at PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA appear to be varied. One recent positive review highlighted the friendly and accommodating service provided by Tim behind the counter and the pizza making skills of Pat. The reviewer specifically praised the "grandma à la vodka" pizza and mentioned that a fresh pizza made for their grandchildren was also enjoyed. They recommended Pellegrino's to others in the area.

However, another customer reported a severe negative experience, claiming to have suffered a foodborne illness after consuming carrot cake purchased from the restaurant. This reviewer detailed a violent illness and expressed a complete loss of trust in the establishment, despite acknowledging that they previously made good pizza.

Given these contrasting recent experiences, it is advisable for potential customers to consider both positive feedback regarding the pizza and service, as well as the serious negative report concerning food safety. For the most current information on their menu and any potential promotions, contacting the restaurant directly may be beneficial.

PELLEGRINO'S PIZZA Location

99 NY-25A #4, Shoreham, NY 11786, USA

Customer Reviews

4.0

170 reviews

Robert Schoenig

Sep 01, 2024

I visited Pellegrino’s yesterday with my 2 Daughters and my grandchildren, Pat was making the pizza. Tim was behind the counter, very friendly, kind, and accommodating with four grandchildren running around their shop grandma à la vodka pizza was out of this world. Pat made a fresh pie for my grandchildren which they enjoyed immensely. I would definitely recommend Pellegrino‘s, if you’re in the area,

kerrie dozier

Dec 09, 2024

Food borne illness from carrot cake bought thursday 12-5. 71 yrs old..cake at 8 pm..sick..violently from 1 am Friday till noon sunday. Baaaad. Shame because they make a good pizza. I can't trust them ever again

Cassidy Schultz

Jun 29, 2024

First and foremost. The service, which has me convinced that I will be making this my designated pizza shop moving forward. Cynthia delivered THE BEST service ever. Greeted me with kindness and was an absolute sweetheart. Everyone else is so great and nice. Couldn’t have asked for a better team to serve food and make customers feel welcomed. Second. The food is 10/10. Love their pizza, deserts, especially their fried Oreos!!! And finally the overall atmosphere of the place is so welcoming and gives off this “mom and pop pizza place” vibe. Just overall the best pizza place in the area!

Lisa Lichelle

Nov 16, 2022

⚡Lisa - UPDATE- 10 ⭐ The box, the pizza, the box, the pizza, THE BOX, THE PIZZA!!! OMG 😮They got a new Holiday Box! Bravo! The Sicilian pizza slice😮OMG! Heaven in my mouth! You know, That's how it's Done! Pelligrino's Pelligrino's ✨ The Best!👍👍👍 - Lisa Lichelle ✨ ⚡ Lisa - Update! Pellegrino's has set the new standard in excellence. I just had the best Chicken Parmesan Pizza Slice on the East Coast. Yeah yeah, I have had pizza up and down the East Coast from Canada, NY to FL. It was the best pizza ever. I had to pull over, look at it and take pictures of it 👀 What! Mannnn Bravo to The Pizza Makers there. WOW! They have set the new 5 Star standard. I might take some other places stars back one, after That 👀 lol. frfr 👀 And Awesome service too. I got my slice while they were finishing up my Delivery order. Bravo, Bravo and Bravissimo 10 Star ⭐ - Lisa Lichelle ✨ ⚡ Lisa - Ahhh Pellegrino's ! Great Service. The friendliest staff. Their customers love them. Quick, efficient, always hot, right off the press. Way to Be! - Lisa Lichelle 🤠

Tim C.

Dec 31, 2024

Best grandma vodka in the business. It’s not even close.