Find My Perfect Chinese Restaurant Near Me

Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar in New Hartford, NY: A Look at Recent Buffet Experiences
  1. Chinese Food
  2. Chinese Restaurant
  3. New York
  4. Oneida County
  5. New Hartford
  6. Chinese Restaurant in Oneida Street
  7. Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar

Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar

447 reviews

Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar Photos

Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 1Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 2Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 3Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 4Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 5Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 6Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 7Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 8Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 9Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar 10

Hours

Monday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Thursday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Sunday, 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

About Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar

Located at 3899 Oneida St in New Hartford, NY, Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar is an establishment that, despite potentially being listed under "Chinese Restaurant" on some platforms, operates as a pizzeria and sports bar. Recent customer reviews focus on their newly introduced buffet and takeaway services, and unfortunately, the feedback has been largely negative.

According to multiple reviews, the experience with the new buffet has been disappointing. Customers have reported issues with the food being old, dried up, and cold. The quality of several items has been criticized, with the pizza described as inedible due to sitting out for an extended period, the riggies tasting like plain canned red sauce, and the vegetables on the salad bar being frozen. One reviewer specifically mentioned the chicken being the only pleasant item they tried.

Concerns have also been raised regarding the service. One customer reported their server never checked on them and spent time eating at the bar, while another mentioned that the bartender frequently walked by their table with empty cups without offering refills and socialized with other tables while neglecting theirs. There were also hygiene issues reported, including a cracked water glass and a squished bug found between plates.

Furthermore, there are discrepancies noted in the pricing. One customer mentioned that the total on their receipt was higher than the expected price based on the per-person buffet cost, even when paying with cash (suggesting it wasn't a credit card service fee). The overall sentiment from these reviews is that the quality of the food does not justify the price, leading at least one customer to leave and make dinner at home instead.

Based on this recent feedback, local users considering the buffet or takeaway from Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar should be aware of the reported issues with food quality, temperature, service, and pricing. While the establishment operates as a pizzeria and sports bar, the recent buffet experience seems to have left a negative impression on several customers. For those still interested, they can be contacted at (315) 737-9172 or +1 315-737-9172. However, it would be wise to consider the recent reviews before making a decision.

Tony's Pizzeria & Sports Bar Location

3899 Oneida St, New Hartford, NY 13413, USA

Customer Reviews

4.0
447 reviews
M
M G
Jan 02, 2025

Was very excited to try the new buffet in hopes to make it a weekly spot. Probably came at a bad hour and it was slow around it so assumably that's why all was old and quite dried up. Was served a glass of water with a crack in it from top to bottom chipped at top.. plate stack had a squished bug between them (it happens just got a different one) pasta salad had tags still attached to the cut tomatoes in it... pizza could not eat had to be there for hours sitting. I don't wanna rag on everything.. The chicken was pleasant. I was able to eat a leg. Otherwise I tried a few items, riggies seemed to taste like red sauce plain.. Server never asked how anything was, just stood at bar eating. Also oddly the price is 15.95 each which would be 31.90 plus tax but the total on the receipt was 33.18 plus tax and I paid cash..( im aware of service fees for credit cards) id rather eat a smaller quantity of items with higher quality. I paid the tab and came home to make dinner instead, waste of 40 bucks.

D
Daniel Roback
Mar 21, 2025

I heard they started a Buffet. me and some family wanted to try it. never again. start off with the food. the food was cold and little to nothing tasted good. the riggies were terrible..tasted like canned sauce. The vegetables on the salad bar were frozen. The service was not too good. the bartender walked by our table constantly as we had empty cups never asked if we wanted refills. never checked on us once. while she would go to other tables and socialize for a few minutes. price was a little outrageous for the quality of frozen food.

S
Sandy Tomaino
Jan 16, 2025

We thought we'd try the lunch buffet. Disappointed for sure. No pizza or bread. Hardly any salad was put out. Most of the food was cold. The 2 beef dishes, meat was tough. Not a good variety. Cake was cut so small you had to take 4 pieces to make a piece of cake. Tried it once that was enough.

S
Samantha
Dec 08, 2024

We have not ordered here in awhile due to it usually being under cooked or over cooked. Tonight we ordered a large pizza and the onions tasted already spoiled and the pizza looked like it sat all day and they just added our topping on and reheated. It sucks to pay so much for food and it to be so bad!

S
SingTrece “SingTrece”
Feb 26, 2023

OmG! I really enjoyed this spot. A pizza with a comedy club inside called Fat Katz. I got to see an amazing host and three phenomenal comedians 💞 The food was amazing and well seasoned. I had the chicken and my husband had the fish and they both were cooked well. My husband loved the spot and we plan on coming back again and it's like 2.5 hours away so that should tell ya something. Worth the stop💞Oh and the servers are very attentive and definitely deserve tips. They were definitely another highlights on this trip especially Jacinta. I hope I spelled her name right but she deserves a raise because she was on point! She was doing it all and never once did I hear her complain. 💗

MORE