The Barile's Planet Pizza

We order from this place at least once a week I prefer to have my pizza with a little crunch to it not doughy when I asked for that yesterday I got very burnt Sicilian pizza for a change when I received it and took it home opened it to find it was burnt to a crisp I also order the wings well done never happens when I can I always tip the delivery person well as I can and if I don’t I pick it or have some pick it up as the case yesterday I don’t know I am so disappointed how could you not know you burnt the pie did you forget it or was it deliberate won’t be ordering that pie anytime soon not from there anyway. I would be embarrassed to serve this.

How do you serve food so horrible? Lived around the street for the longest and always pass by when I go to the dollar store. I finally tried it and this screams disappointment. You have to do better, this is the meatball you are serving people that is worst than high school lunch. When you cut into the meatball, it’s hard and the taste is horrible, not even heat could make it better. For the price, you guys have to provide better food. You’ve definitely lost a perspective customer. I wish the food was as good as the service. The Caesar salad taste disgusting and the pizza is subpar. I don’t recommend.

I've ordered pizza here about 6 times so far, so all I can speak to is the pizza, haven't tried anything else yet. I always order the same thing, "large pie please, well done, you know crispy like a cracker with sauce and cheese". The first times I could tell it was just left in longer as the cheese was as done more than the crust, instead of being put on a hot spot in the oven when close to taking out. Not optimal, but good all the same. Plus, people get offended if I say to put it on the hot spot (I used to make pizza) so I just let it go rather than offend anyone with direct access to my food. Anyway, today, Sunday 10/27/24 at around 3pm I stopped by and ordered the same. Saw a new pizzaman that I hadn't seen before so expected the same, good but not spectacular. Boy was I wrong! This guy made it absolutely perfect, crispy but not burnt top or bottom, even after getting home it was still crispy as a cracker in the humid box. I was so impressed I called to compliment and was moved to make this review. This pizza man definitely put it on a hot spot just like the best do, felt like I was back in BK for the day, thank you Barile's, hired a great pizza guy! Feel confident ordering other items now, I'm super picky and tend to not like dining or take out after delivering to some of the most expensive places like country clubs in Westchester and valet parking restaurants in Greenwich and being behind the scenes. Enjoy ordering here though, never saw any of the telltale signs about cleanliness or employee dissatisfaction. Definitely recommend ordering crispy pizza here, just use the key words is all so no misunderstanding can happen.

This was a delightful find. We were staying in the area and Google maps led us to this pizza place. So, so delicious 😋 Was made perfectly to our request and tasted great. Hands down the best cheese steak I've had in years. So very happy with this experience 😁

First time ordering from this pizzeria. Ordered a large pie, meatballs, mozzarella sticks, the chili calamari, and beef patty. Spent $83, wouldn’t order from here again or recommend. The calamari which was almost $20 was so over cooked it was like rubber. The mozzarella stickers were also severely over cooked as the beef patties were too. The pizza was ok but had no sauce on it. The meatballs were very good but not worth being a returning customer.