Sicily's Pizza St. Martin

I was really hoping for something special or unique knowing this is a local pizza buffet restaurant. Unfortunately despite the almost 20 different types of pizza and countless different sides from pasta to lasagna to fried chicken that was available, it fell short of my expectations. The quality of the ingredients was below other chain pizza buffet restaurants and the flavor of the pizza was nothing to get excited about. The service however was excellent. The staff quickly cleared empty plates and cleaned off the tables. The salad bar was decent and probably the best part of my visit here. If you are looking for a buffet with lots of different types of pizza then this may be for you. Unfortunately this was not for me.

We were pretty upset for our first time here. The food is average taste. They do have a lot of variety of pizza and it is nice to see so many other options to make the whole family happy. The Sicilian kicking chicken was the best thing in the buffet. Our waitress was the sweetest women and super fast. However, we were upset to be charged 3.9% to use a card. We called before we went and they never mentioned it when we asked about pricing. We also called ahead to see if they would honor my bariatric card . The man on the phone said no problem I would just be charged the kids price for a 12 year old. When we arrived the cashier didn’t know what the card was so she called a man from the back to help. His disposition was clear that he was not happy about me using my card. He shook his head at me with an attitude the whole time she rang it up and continued to shake his head in disgust all the way back to the kitchen. We would have walked out and left after this if we didn’t have a toddler that was not going to leave without pizza. The way he handled the situation was rude and uncalled for. If it made him that angry he could have just said he would not honor it and go on instead of embarrassing me. The 3 star rating is more for the treatment and price than the food itself. The food was good just not great for the price. Unless you really want to try a bunch of different pizzas, pay the extra and go to the palace buffet instead. We will not be back but if we had been treated differently we might have given it one more chance.

Pizza buffet with a surprising amount of options. There were at least 2doz varieties for pizza alone, plus a soup and salad bar, pastas and other entrees. I've never been to a pizza buffet with fried pickles and chicken. Ice cream and dessert pizzas fill out the selections. If you have a picky eater this might be the place for you. Large eating area could accommodate several large groups. As far as buffets go, it was nothing spectacular. Everything looked clean and fresh food was regularly rotated while I was there. Beverages are self serve, but wait staff would come and clear your table of used dishes. Food isn't great, but it isn't terrible either, you get what you pay for. This is more of a place to take a family or the team/squad, so expect that type of atmosphere, with kids being kids. Tuesdays is kids 12 and under eat free, make sure you tip the staff for their patience God bless them. They have a small arcade in the corner, so you may want to bring, or leave your quarters at home.

There two locations within driving distance, this one and the one in Gulfport. I recommend the Gulfport location over this one. They are both stocked about the same, but the set up is slightly different, and the staff is friendlier in Gulfport. That being said we did not have any problems at this location, the other just seemed better overall.

We visited this establishment today. We were greeted soon as we walked in. The guy was super nice and very friendly. The restaurant was super clean, along with the bathrooms and buffet line. They were playing some pretty good music. We had view of the kitchen and it was pretty awesome to see them making pizzas. Our waitress Tracey was pretty awesome, attentive, kept the table cleaned of plates and made sure we were good at all times. Now let's talk about the food. The fried chicken was sooooo freaking good along with the fried okra. Every pizza we tried it was super delicious. We tried the supreme pizza cajun pizza, pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, chicken bacon ranch pizza, and the muffuletta pizza. Once again, they were all delicious and tasty! The dessert pizzas, brownies, chocolate pudding and bread pudding were delicious also. I would highly recommend this place and the price is very reasonable. Keep up the great work!