Pueblo Viejo

Pueblo Viejo is a Mexican restaurant located at 158 NY-52, Carmel Hamlet, NY 10512. They can be reached at (845) 228-2504 or +1 845-228-2504.

Based on customer reviews, Pueblo Viejo is a popular spot in the area, known for its consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere. Customers frequently praise the margaritas, chips, salsa, and guacamole, highlighting their consistently good taste. The "Tres Amigos" dish is also a favorite, with customers expressing satisfaction with the portion size and flavor.

The restaurant is described as having a surprisingly nice ambiance and excellent service. The fresh, tableside guacamole and shrimp ceviche are highly recommended. Although some customers found the food to be good rather than exceptional, they were generally satisfied with their meals.

One point of contention among reviewers was the restaurant's ability to prepare certain mixed drinks, specifically mules. While the restaurant is known for its margaritas, mules were reported to be inconsistent, with some needing to be sent back. However, the friendly staff and excellent service contributed to a positive overall experience, and many customers expressed their intention to return.

In summary, Pueblo Viejo offers a pleasant dining experience with consistently good Mexican cuisine and drinks, particularly their margaritas and guacamole. The restaurant's friendly staff and good service are also notable. Customers should be aware that certain mixed drinks may not be consistently prepared.