Port Jervis Brick Oven Pizza

Their lasagna is good flavor wise but the meat to cheese ratio is WAY off. I’ve attached a picture. It looks a bit broken up because I was searching for cheese. It’s literally just noodles with meat. The ONLY cheese on it was a big slice of mozzarella on top. The penne ala vodka hardly had any chicken in it. SO Disappointing. I spent $52 for the entire order - Didn’t include the 2 apps in my review. Again, so disappointed.

I'm from long island and am a pizza snob. Was pleasantly surprised with the pizza here. Good crust. Definitely use good cheese. Will be stopping to pick up pizza on the weekend

Tried this place again after 4 months …. Disappointed smh. $30 later & the pizza was SOGGY & really tough at the same time. There wasnt a cheese pull there was a dough pull & a struggle to cut it with my teeth. I don’t think anyone knows how to make real NY pizza in this town. That was my last shot with them, I won’t be returning. Sidenote, I really think the people saying the pizza here is amazing in the reviews are being paid or maybe they got lucky one day. This places food is not good. Their pizza is soggy & over sauced. You want crispy crust? I think you have to get one of slices that’s been sitting on the counter for hours not a fresh pie. The dough also has absolutely NO favor. Stick to a cheese slice on the counter or if you do want a fresh pie DO NOT get any toppings! Soggy, soggy, soggy!!!! Nice people but the food is NOT good & worth the money.

Excellent food started with slices and canoli ordered again the next day for delivery! The biggest calzone we have seen at 14 inches across with an Greek salad and a canoli of course! Highly recommend this place!

It's like you can't get hot food from this place unless you eat here in the little section they have. Asked for my pizza to be put in after a little while because a hero was going to take 20 mins, they put the pizza right in the oven, so I reiterate that I would like my pizza hot when the hero is ready. I come back 10 mins later, I see the pizza and the garlic knots (if you can call them that) was already on top of the oven, like that was gonna keep them warm. 5 more mins the hero comes out and they still didn't give me the food for several more, the place was busy at this point so I didn't know what was actually mine, or I would have said something. It's just crazy how such a simple request can be neglected. I have no idea what how food tastes like from this place. Delivery, pick up.... womp womp womp, bottom line is they don't care enough to follow a simple customer request. I had to stop ordering delivery from this place 2 years ago because I live a block away and they still got the food to us cold. It was ridiculous. Well, maybe we will try again in another 2 years. Lol