Old Xi’an

Welcome to Old Xi’an, a Chinese restaurant situated at 164 Pearl St #10, New York, NY 10005, USA. Located in the Financial District of New York City, Old Xi’an aims to offer a taste of Xi’an cuisine to local residents and visitors. They can be contacted at (212) 797-5338 or their mobile number, +1 212-797-5338, for inquiries or to place orders for takeout or to inquire about dine-in options.

Based on the limited customer feedback available online, Old Xi’an has received predominantly negative reviews, with customers expressing significant disappointment in the food's presentation, taste, and authenticity. One customer who ordered the Vegetable Hand-Ripped Noodle In Soup (substituting rice noodles) on March 24th shared their experience, including a comparison between a photo from the restaurant's website and the dish they received. This customer found the received dish to be "completely disappointing," and noted that the taste did not compensate for the poor presentation.

Another review echoed this sentiment of disappointment, stating that the place was a "huge disappointment." This customer, who expressed excitement at trying Old Xi’an due to their fondness for Xi’an Famous Foods and hopes for a similar experience, found the noodles to be a major letdown. They described the noodles as "big, flat, soft, and just boring," lacking the expected chewiness and the characteristics of hand-pulled noodles. Both the spicy beef noodle soup and the vegetarian noodle soup ordered by this customer were deemed "extremely disappointing," with the vegetarian option being particularly criticized for lacking flavor and being bland and boring.

Furthermore, this reviewer also commented on the spicy cumin lamb burger and the beef burger, finding both to be "way too salty" and lacking flavor. The chicken dry noodle was also described as "bad." The customer concluded by expressing their disappointment that a place with a "cute" ambiance failed to deliver on the culinary expectations, labeling it a failed "copy cat of Xian Famous food." They also asserted that those who found the food good likely do not have a good understanding of Chinese food.

The environment of Old Xi’an is described by one reviewer as "cute," suggesting that the restaurant might have a pleasant or appealing physical setting. However, this positive note about the ambiance is overshadowed by the negative feedback regarding the food itself. The location in the Financial District implies that it might cater to the lunchtime crowd from nearby offices as well as local residents and tourists. The size of the establishment (indicated by #10 in the address) is not clear from the provided information.

In terms of services, Old Xi’an likely offers both dine-in and takeout options, given its nature as a restaurant and the fact that customers have ordered and received food. The availability of a phone number suggests that phone orders for takeout are accepted. It is not explicitly mentioned whether they offer delivery services directly or through third-party platforms. Local users interested in delivery should inquire when contacting the restaurant.

The features of Old Xi’an are intended to be its take on Xi’an cuisine, with a focus on hand-ripped noodles and dishes like spicy beef noodle soup, vegetarian noodle soup, spicy cumin lamb burger, beef burger, and chicken dry noodle. However, based on the reviews, the execution of these dishes appears to be a significant issue. Customers have criticized the noodles for lacking the expected texture and flavor, the soups for being bland and disappointing, and the burgers for being overly salty and lacking overall flavor. The comparison to Xi’an Famous Food sets a benchmark that Old Xi’an reportedly fails to meet in terms of authenticity and taste.

Promotional information is not available in the provided reviews. It is unknown if Old Xi’an offers any specials, lunch deals, or other promotions to attract customers. Those interested in such offers would need to contact the restaurant directly.

The overwhelmingly negative feedback in the available reviews paints a concerning picture of Old Xi’an. Customers have expressed strong disappointment with the food's presentation, taste, texture, and authenticity, particularly when compared to established Xi’an cuisine. The issues span across various dishes, including their signature hand-ripped noodles and other menu items. While the ambiance might be appealing to some, the core offering – the food – has been significantly criticized.

For local users in the Financial District of New York City, Old Xi’an is geographically accessible. However, the strong negative reviews regarding the quality and authenticity of the food should serve as a significant warning. If you are familiar with and enjoy authentic Xi’an cuisine, the reviews suggest that Old Xi’an might not meet your expectations. Those unfamiliar with this type of food might also be disappointed based on the described lack of flavor and poor execution.

Given the consistent negative feedback across multiple dishes and from different customers, potential patrons should exercise caution. If you are considering trying Old Xi’an, it might be advisable to have low expectations or perhaps inquire further about recent changes or improvements in their food preparation. Reading more reviews from other platforms, if available, could also provide a broader perspective.

To obtain the most current information about their menu, hours of operation, and any potential delivery services, as well as to inquire about the issues raised in the reviews, please contact Old Xi’an directly at (212) 797-5338 or +1 212-797-5338. However, based on the strong negative sentiment in the provided feedback, exploring other Chinese restaurant options in the area might be a more satisfying choice for those seeking quality and authentic flavors.

In conclusion, Old Xi’an in the Financial District of New York City has received significant negative feedback regarding the presentation, taste, and authenticity of its Xi’an-style cuisine, particularly its hand-ripped noodles and other signature dishes. Local users should be aware of these criticisms when considering dining at or ordering from this establishment.