O Sole Mio Cucina Italiana

The waiters were great and the atmosphere was good too. I ordered a dish with ziti pasta in it, but got penne pasta instead. I looked up other images of their ziti dishes afterwards and noticed that they just do that. Not sure if they just didn’t have it in stock, but it would’ve been nice to know before I ordered that they had to substitute.

What a wonderful little gem! The servers were all attentive, kind and courteous, Ben in particular. Even with a busy rush of dinner, food came out quickly. The food quality is incomparable to other places in the area, and the restaurant is very accommodating to reasonable plate modifications. Well worth the price and the drive! A location in downtown Gainesville would thrive.

This is a very nice looking restaurant and I had high hopes since it has good ratings. However the food was not impressive. The sauces drown the pasta and it ruins the dishes. Flavorful but does not feel authentic. The service was also inconsistent.

What a nice restaurant! Service from Elsa was just great! She was friendly and provided some wonderful recommendations. My wife thoroughly enjoyed the eggplant with gluten free noodles. I had the spaghetti carbonara which wasn't on the menu but was on the specials menu. It does come with a lot of sauce but the portion size is excellent! Very tasty. There is a good selection of cheesecake as well. Worth a try!

O Sole Mio Cucina Italiana in Newberry is a true gem that brings authentic Italian flavors to life in every dish. From the moment I walked in, the warm ambiance and friendly staff made me feel right at home. The star of the evening was undoubtedly the cauliflower crust pizza—an absolute must-try! The Aloha pizza, with its perfect balance of sweet and savory, was a delightful surprise that exceeded all my expectations. The seafood oasis is a culinary masterpiece, showcasing fresh, vibrant flavors that transport you straight to the coast of Italy. Each bite was packed with the taste of the sea—perfectly cooked and beautifully presented. I couldn't resist trying the penne burins, which was rich, creamy, and simply divine. It was a comforting dish that perfectly embodied the rich tradition of Italian cuisine. To complement our meal, the homemade garlic bread—crusty, buttery, and fragrant with garlic—it was irresistible! And let's not forget about dessert; they were truly amazing! Each sweet treat was crafted with precision and bursting with flavor, providing the perfect end to a fantastic meal. Overall, O Sole Mio Cucina Italiana is a must-visit for anyone craving top-notch Italian food. From the incredible dishes to the inviting atmosphere, it’s an experience worth savoring. I can't wait to return and indulge in more of their culinary delights!