Nicolosi's Pizzeria and Restaurant

This place is so cool. I drove 50 miles for lunch from Philadelphia just to taste the delicious food and see the super cool horror themed atmosphere. The Skull Knots were soooo good. The Pizza steak was delicious, and the BBQ chicken Pizza was the best I ever had. I definitely recommend locals and people further as the town and general area are historic and the nature is beautiful.

Absolutely Horrific… and We Loved It! Nicolosi’s Pizzeria in Forks Township delivers an absolutely horrific atmosphere—and I mean that in the best way possible! The entire theme of the restaurant is horror, and they truly commit to it. From spooky posters to creepy characters lurking in the seating area, it’s like dining in a fun haunted house. My kids (and nephews) were both intrigued and thrilled—scared, but the fun kind of scared that turns into excitement and laughter. The staff was beyond sweet and incredibly accommodating, especially when it came to customizing meals for each of the kids’ quirky preferences (and we all know how picky kids can be). They handled everything with smiles and patience, and that alone deserves a shout-out. If I had one small wish—it’s that they offered pasta. It’s a pretty standard option in most pizzerias, and I think it would be a great addition here. But honestly, that’s just nitpicking. It’s become a new favorite spot for me while my kid is at dance, and I’m looking forward to making it a regular experience when we have little visitors. Creepy vibes, tasty food, and kind-hearted people? Count us in!

Drove 90 minutes from North Jersey to see this place and have lunch. I saw that they opened at 11AM .. so that is when I showed up. It was perfect because there were no other customers yet, and I was able to take a lot of pictures. Don't look at my pics if you want to go and be surprised. If you like great pizza and cheesesteaks and horror movies, you will love it. It's always Halloween at this place. Super cool. Owner and employees were very nice, too! I love that they are getting so popular. Good for them!

I recently visited Nicolosi's and had a decent experience. The atmosphere was fun and the decorations were creative. I saw a video posted to Facebook about it's fun theme on horror movies and decided to try it out. However, the pizza was just okay. We ordered a Hawaiian pizza, which came with (I'm pretty sure) canned pineapple - a bit of a letdown, as fresh pineapple would have made a big difference. My parents seemed to like their BBQ pizza, which did look better! On the other hand, the skull garlic knots were a highlight - crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, just right. Overall, I'd say a thumbs up is given for its unique atmosphere. Howver, I'd maybe stick with simpler/basic pizzas if headed to try. Rating: 3.5/5 stars

What a great, new (to us) find. This restaurant has a horror movie theme and is decorated with all kinds of great horror memorabilia. A lot of times, when you go to a themed restaurant, they only do the "gimmick" well, or they do the food well, but never both. And sometimes they miss the mark on both. But here, owner Jason does a great job on both the decor and the food. We had the pizza, which is an outstanding New York style with a really thin crust and a super flavorful sauce. We also had their skull-shaped garlic knots. We tried them topped with cinnamon sugar and served with blood-red frosting, which were pretty good. But get them smothered in garlic and oil and dip them in Jason's fantastic sauce. We'll definitely be back.