Magoya

I went to Magoya Japanese Restaurant in Chester, New York and had salmon tartare, spicy tuna roll, yama roll and cucumber dish. All the food was made without seasoning and was authentic and delicious.

Honestly wasn’t bad just overall weird experience. I didn’t enjoy my sushi as much as I would have liked to. I was honestly scared by some of the textures in my spicy tuna roll. Their dining room is aesthetically pleasing but I would say the restaurant itself is in an awkward place (like parking and residence near it seemed confusing). We were the only ones in the restaurant, so service felt a bit awkward but server was very attentive. I don’t personally think I would go out of my way again for it.

Nice place and the sushi is great. Little pricey, but great quality sushi. Love the spicy crab salad/ kani salad. They make it so different than other places. It’s a must try. Like the soup selection, wish they have something with gluten free noodles. Dessert menu is great too.

I had such a great experience overall. I just so happen to be in the area and search stuff. This place decided to give it a try. The food was phenomenal. Very tasty fresh the whole 9 yards. Our server was super nice and super attentive. The seating wasn’t the most comfortable being that it was just traditional wooden benches. But I get it because the decor in the restaurant is very traditional besides, that the place looks very nice the lighting and everything as you can see in the pictures the food that we’ve ordered. All in all due to my experience, that totally deserves the five stars. Oh, and also, it was an expensive at all and the quality of the food was most definitely fresh. If I’m ever in this area again, rest assured, I will be back.

Atmosphere was great and thought we gonna have fantastic experience here. We were wrong. 1st, the server would not bring a glass of water to my 5 year old. I thought she forgot and reminded her but still no water was brought to my kid. 2nd, it took probably 45 min for the miso soup to be served and forever for the bento boxes to come out. 3rd, the sashimi was a disappointment- the color and texture of the tuna were not good. 4th, I was charged extra dollar for the roll we ordered. When I pointed it out, the server brought out her notebook and said it was increased. I asked her to check the menu (because that’s what we were given to order food, not the notebook!) and I was right. She then said I could deduct one dollar from the tip… wouldn’t come again and won’t recommend anyone to come.