Macy’s Place Pizzeria

I enjoy Macy’s Place occasionally - my problem is their consistency with their food. The price I just paid for mediocre food is beyond me. I ordered extra cheese (double cheese) and pepperoni, wings medium extra crispy - what I received was a cheese and pepperoni pizza (barely any cheese on the outer slices and pepperoni barely there, center of pizza WET because it was barely done, medium wings wet barely crispy. My suggestion is if you order today and it’s good, don’t go back for at least 3 month because if you go the next day or the next week, THEY WILL MISS - I promise you they will. They have all these amazing sounding items, but what good is it if it’s not cooked consistently every time it’s ordered!

I have been ordering from Macy’s place pizzeria for several years. I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni half sausage and onions and it took about 50 min to come, no problem but when it got here it was a chicken and waffle pizza , I called immediately to tell them they delivered the wrong pie. They said they were going to pick up the pizza( as if they were going to deliver it to someone after it was in my house) and they picked it up and said they were going to re make it and deliver me a new one that took about 45 min. They didn’t offer anything for the mishap after we called back to complain they gave us a $20 credit for next time… We vowed it wouldn’t be a next time but like idiots we ordered again I used the $20 credit and ordered a half sheet cheese and pepperoni and 30 wings it came up to $63 , $43 with the $20 credit. When it got here and I sat it down and opened it , it was a cheese pizza no pepperoni and barely no cheese basically sauce and bread! I’m so done with Macy’s that I didn’t even bother to call and complain, they obviously don’t care about their customers! I WILL NEVER ORDER AGAIN! And I’m sure they don’t care but be aware they use to be a Good pizza place to order from but they have truly went down hill… By the way I always leave a tip but it seems like you get treated worse when you do, so don’t bother.

Two years ago we stumbled across Macy’s on our trip to see family in Buffalo. I had heard about it on Twitter and convinced my wife to give it a try. What we experienced was some of our favorite pizza we’ve ever had. Fast forward to present day and another trip to Buffalo. We knew Macy’s would be a spot but hoped we hadn’t romanticized it too much over the last two years. Nope, we hadn’t. It was just as good as the first time. Excellent pizza. We also went with a cookies and cream dessert pizza. It was pure sugar bliss. I can’t recommend this place enough. Side note: they forgot to cut the dessert pizza which initially was a problem but allowed me to cut a piece as big as I wanted which had positives… and negatives. 🤣

Friends and I got to drinking and that took us down a path of where to go for late night eats. At 9pm we came across Macy’s on Google and looked at their menu. It’s so vast I’m sure it’s a few pages long. They have the whackiest creations and dessert pizza. We went with the snorkin and porkin which was Mac and cheese base with bbq pulled pork chunks. Then for dessert we did the Oreo cookie pizza which is a canolli cream base with crushed Oreos, chocolate sauce, and powdered sugar on top. Both were insanely good and it hit the spot for us. Generous toppings make these slices FILLING which leaves you plenty for leftovers. We had the rest the next day for lunch. If you’re in the area definitely check it out.

Second or third time ordering from this location. I love their sauce. Not super sweet but just sweet enough. Love the sauce. The great amount of cheese. The pepperoni were great. Not cup char but it worked well. Soft bite no tear which is how I prefer my pizza. Ordered 20 wings med. also loved the sauce/flavor. Cooked crispy. Very good. Large cheese pepperoni 20 wings on a Monday cost $44 thank you