Joey Fratello's Pizzeria in Findlay, OH

Chinese Restaurant Ohio Hancock County Findlay East Sandusky Street

539 reviews

116 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
+1 419-427-5639
webSite

Hours

Monday, Closed
Tuesday, 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday, 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday, 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday, 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday, 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Sunday, 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

About Joey Fratello's Pizzeria

Joey Fratello's Pizzeria, located at 116 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, is a local pizzeria offering a variety of pizzas, calzones, and sandwiches. You can reach them at (419) 427-5639 or +1 419-427-5639.

Customer reviews indicate a mixed experience, with some finding the food and service to be good, while others have noted some areas for improvement. The restaurant is described as a local spot, which can be good for gatherings.

Here's a summary of customer experiences:

Customers have noted varying experiences with the atmosphere and service, with some reporting improvements over time.
The calzone is highlighted as a standout item on the menu.
The pizza is considered decent, especially with pepperoni, but the plain cheese pizza received less favorable reviews.
The pizza sauce is noted for its unique sweetness and is a highlight for many customers.
Ingredients are described as being of decent quality, a step above chain restaurant standards.
The restaurant has a cooler for self-serve drinks and desserts.
The atmosphere is described as a little run down, and the restaurant is relatively small.
Customers have also noted the red sauce can be cold, and the lack of pizza holders can cause space issues.
Sandwiches are considered good, but not the highlight of the meal.

Joey Fratello's Pizzeria offers a local pizza experience with a unique sauce. While the atmosphere and some aspects of the food have received mixed reviews, the calzone and the sauce are generally well-received. If you're looking for a local pizza spot in Findlay, OH, this pizzeria provides a variety of options. Be aware that the restaurant is not very large, and the atmosphere may be considered a little run-down by some.

Joey Fratello's Pizzeria Location

116 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA

Customer Reviews

4.0

539 reviews

Luke Dice

Nov 22, 2023

I have been here twice, both exactly a year apart. The first time I went I was not too impressed both with the atmosphere, taste, and service. The second time I went, my mind was completely changed. Our server was kind, attentive, and ready to help wherever she could. The food was pretty good. Pizza is hard to review because everyone has a personal preference, but overall it’s not a bad pie if you add pepperoni. I did not enjoy the plain pie. Surprisingly the calzone was the star of the show. I would have a slice or two of that again. Main reasons for the lack of 5 stars are the atmosphere (things are a little run down), the lack of pizza holders so you don’t have too much room, the cold red sauce, and the overall taste. Would recommend anything other than the cheese pizza.

Lisa I. S. A.

Aug 27, 2023

Pizza is pizza but Joey's sauce is the real winner. It has a bit of sweetness to it. Ingredients are a decent quality and a step up from a chain. As you walk in there is a cooler to grab drinks and dessert. It's a great local spot to gather but keep in mind it isn't a huge restaurant so be ready for your pizza to come out hot! Sandwich was pretty good but not the highlight of the meal.

Marnie Carpenter

Jun 11, 2024

In town visiting family found this place on Google. The pizza was very good. Better than the other pizza restaurants in Findlay. The prices on Google are much lower than the actual price. Person working there said the prices on Facebook were correct. Will definitely be back when I'm in town again.

Ellie P.

Mar 18, 2023

Delicious option for lunch or dinner on the road. I called to order when we were ab 25min away and when I arrived everything was ready, warm and tasting amazing. I loved that you can customize your calzone. Friendly and helpful staff as well.

Cyndy Rotman

Nov 09, 2024

The food was wonderful, but your in restaurant dining is awful! We waited 1- 1/2 hours for our appetizer, then additional time for our pizza. I never expected to be put in front of all the online takeout orders but you must learn to merge your in restaurant guests for a reasonable time to sit and wait for their meal. If you had other customers waiting for a table, they would never get seated.