Gary's Restaurant

Gary's Restaurant is located at 6367 Lakeshore Rd S in Canastota, NY. They can be contacted at (315) 762-5516 or +1 315-762-5516.

Customer reviews for Gary's Restaurant present significantly contrasting experiences. One reviewer reported an "absolutely horrible experience all the way around," stating that three out of four meals were awful. They described a grizzly and boiled-tasting, overcooked strip steak, an undercooked sirloin steak, and scallops smaller than a dime. This reviewer also mentioned finding hair in the food, a wait time of over an hour for the meal, a rude waitress, and unsanitary conditions, including a moldy soap dispenser in a run-down building. They were extremely dissatisfied and suggested the health department should shut the place down.

In stark contrast, another customer who visited for the first time found the place to be "great, nice and homey." They described the food as "fantastic," with their husband's steak cooked perfectly and their scallops parmesan with angel hair pasta being excellent. They also enjoyed the "hodgepodge," a variety of finger foods with what appeared to be homemade breading, and found the salads to be wonderful with many extras. This reviewer enthusiastically recommended Gary's Restaurant to everyone.

While the platform categorizes Gary's Restaurant as a Chinese Restaurant, the customer reviews do not mention Chinese cuisine. Instead, they refer to dishes like steak, scallops parmesan with angel hair pasta, and a hodgepodge of finger foods, as well as salads. Potential local users should be aware of the widely differing opinions regarding the quality of food, service, and the overall condition of the restaurant when considering a visit.