Four Brothers Pizza Inn

This restaurant has an identity crisis. It can't decide whether it is a Greek Diner or an Italian restaurant. We ordered a Greek salad and a half meat-lovers and half Vegetarian salad. Neither dish left me wanting for more. There were less than ten people in the restaurant with one waitress who also bussed the tables. She was pleasant but didn't seem particularly present. This was the first restaurant in Rhinebeck that was disappointing.

Delicious, wholesome food at fair prices. Very friendly, efficient waitress. This branch of Four Brothers looks nothing like the other branches, so I suspect that it may have once been a fused part of the neighboring restaurant, Country Kitchens. Small, single occupant bathroom, but clean. Free wi-fi and ample parking. My only suggestion is for the installation of coat hooks at the booths, since my party’s coats kept falling off the booth’s seat onto the floor, and I saw no coat rack in the restaurant.

As my experience for 20+ years eating four brothers food I think it's gone downhill for sure. The pizza quality is less than it used to be and they charge a whole lot more. The salad I got the other day was a small tossed and even the lettuce was less and brown! The large pizzas used to be bigger and bigger boxes and now their smaller and pizza just isn't the same overall and charging more money for lower quality is just a joke and disrespectful!

Usually a 5 star experience when I'm visiting the family from TN. The take out of a 4 meat pie and gyro really just didn't live up to the expectations this time unfortunately. Food was definitely edible but because of the high standard they set for themselves it missed the mark. While I was a little disappointed, I won't let one mediocre experience keep me from expecting the best from them next time.

Visited on the recommendation of a friend when I wanted Greek food (The owners are Greek) but the only Greek items on the menu were gyros, salad and spinach pie. The chicken on my gyro was very dry and the salad had too much feta. Both were mediocre at best. The calzone was a little overdone but good. The place was a bit shabby and the carpet definitely needed to be replaced. If you are in the mood for Italian food in this is your place.