Catanzareti Pizza

•Update to add: if you haven’t tried their grandma pie which is a square garlicky perfection, please do. It is outstanding and incredibly delicious. You’re welcome ;) Great place for a local pie. Their pizza is our go-to for our weekly pizza fix. They were closed a day recently and we were forced to try another Lambertville pizzeria. What a disappointment. This place will always have our business. Fresh and delicious.

Absolute amazing pizza. Very kind and genuine service. Will choose this place every time I come to new hope/ lambertville.

Best pie in the area, hands down. If you want each bite to be as good as first slice you ever had as a kid this is the spot!

5 stars i used to get a pie every week ten years ago on Sunday nights before walking dead it was always great...we moved..just moved back into town and we started going and getting pies like once a week again still Just as good.the crust is always crunchy and bubbly.just honest good jersey pizza and it's actully not outrageous prices like every other place in Lambertville.also thry have super good cheese cake it's only 3.50 a slice I get it every time!

Stopped here on a whim. Large pie to go, peppers and onion. Awesome tasting pizza pie with generous toppings that were fresh. Ordered the pie and waited in the car. Thunderstorm broke out. Pouring... Gentleman behind the counter saw me getting out of my car and came to the shop door to indicate that I should wait and he would deliver our pie to car. I declined his offer but, really, this level of service for an order less than $20.00? Where do you see that anymore? We consider ourselves pizza snobs from New York City. This is only the second pizzeria to pass muster in 15 years of living in New Jersey and we will be regular customers going forward. Thank you, Catanzareti Pizza. Kenny