Burger 25 Toms River

3.5* is more accurate, I want to put 4* so bad but I'm pissed they shrinkflation'd their mozzarella sticks. They might as well be using frozen ones. They used to be so good like true boardwalk mozzarella sticks Anyway, for the good stuff - Insanely good fries and garlic ranch dip - My favorite mint chocolate chip shake (the thin mint one) - Their peanut butter shakes are also really good - One of their burgers of the month (Nov?) was the Tailgater and my absolute favorite burger of all time. It was weirdly not too much. Patty, onion bun, chili, Fritos, and chipotle mayo. I wish it was still on the menu - Prices still reasonable for me, plus insane fries portion - Cookie dough balls I wish their bacon was actually extremely crispy (think of Jersey Mike's bacon) I've seen a lot of people mention their quality went down since they expanded. I have been with Burger 25 since before COVID started and at their og location, and it was definitely better then, but by no means bad now as long as they keep their fries the way they are and don't go crazy on prices

We had a nice experience at Burger 25! We ordered the Classic Cheeseburger with onion rings and the Mushroom Swiss Burger with fries—both were delicious. The service was quick and friendly, and everything came out fresh and hot. We were too full to try the milkshakes this time, but they looked amazing, so we’ll definitely be back for them.

The burgers here are great, but the real standout is their milkshakes, absolutely the best! They offer a wide selection of burgers, including chicken options. I enjoy dining in because of the cozy atmosphere and dim lighting, which adds a unique vibe (though that might just be my personal preference). Honestly, I’d choose this place over Five Guys!

Hands down the best burger in the area. You can normally get a seat without to much trouble, warm weather brings extra outdoor seats. Staff is super friendly. Have gone many times without one issue. BYOB

Super good food! This is probably one of the best restaurants in jersey and it is fairly priced. I highly recommend to anyone with a family looking for a place to eat