Aversano's Restaurant - Catering - Pizzeria

We had lunch today on the Pizza section of this restaurant. Over-met my expectations for food, service and atmosphere. We had to run a few errands in Brewster today and have not visited Aversanos in quite a few years. Consistently meet our expectations both in the semi formal dining restaurant and the casual pizza. We recommend you try the eggplant panini with salad. Yum! Parking is plentiful. Seating is spacious and handicapped friendly. 10/07/2024 1pm

We had a wedding dinner with 40+ people to celebrate our marriage/elopement. The restaurant made the process very simple and they were very accommodating. The appetizers, entrées, and desserts were absolutely delicious as expected and the service the night of was above and beyond. They made our wedding dinner extra special. They allowed us to bring centerpieces for the table and a few outside items to display around our wedding cake. I can’t recommend this place enough whether for date night or a special event! Love this place ❤️

Food was good. Waitress was confused and forgetful. Need more staff to attend tables. Portions were not great. I order Shrimp Fra Diablo which was good which was a dinner but looked like an appetizer. Fried calamari was undercooked. And one of the waitresses was very rude. They want to make it a five star restaurant. It’s still a pizzeria. Not impressed. If you are hungry don’t bother going there.

There was a time I felt this place was 5 stars, but now I would consider it "hit or miss". Sometimes when dining in, the meals and drinks were excellent, but yesterday we were disappointed in our pizza. We ordered a half cheese/half pepperoni, and it was obviously reheated slices instead of a fresh pie. I just feel that sometimes they cut corners and sacrifice quality.

My husband and I enjoy trying new places and absolutely loved Aversano’s! We have lived fairly close to this gem for a years now and have heard wonderful things about it so we decided to try and it did not disappoint. Everyone is so warm and welcoming, and the food was so delicious and fresh. Although a little small, the restaurant has a very cozy feeling to it. We had apps, entrees, and dessert - all 10/10. Toasted almond tiramisu - oh my gosh! We will definitely be back and so happy this place is so close!